In a recent interview, Tony Gilroy, the creator of the acclaimed series Andor, expressed his profound disappointment over the Emmy snubs for lead actor Diego Luna and supporting actress Genevieve O’Reilly. Despite the show’s critical acclaim, these oversights have sparked discussions about the nature of awards and the political themes within the series.
‘Andor’ Emmy Snubs: A Painful Reflection by Creator Tony Gilroy
For fans of the Star Wars series Andor, few Emmy snubs stood out more on nominations morning than the absence of lead Diego Luna in the title role and season standout Genevieve O’Reilly as Mon Mothma in the supporting category.
Creator Tony Gilroy’s Disappointment
Creator Tony Gilroy expressed his disappointment regarding these omissions.
Despite the show’s success in its second and final season — including nominations for Best Drama Series, Writing, Directing, and Guest Actor for Forest Whitaker — the accolades did not fully acknowledge the exceptional work that Gilroy witnessed on the show.
A Candid Conversation with Gold Derby
In a candid conversation with Gold Derby, Gilroy reflects on his awards history, including his journey through the film circuit with Michael Clayton in 2007-08, what nominations signify to him, and whether Andor was as political as some online critics claimed.
The Importance of Awards
Gold Derby: You’ve navigated the awards circuit with Andor Season 1 and previously with Michael Clayton. What are your thoughts on awards in general?
Tony Gilroy: I grew up watching awards shows, and they seemed significant when I wasn’t part of the movie business. Early in my career, I observed some individuals altering their paths to gain recognition, making non-creative choices. It’s a complex and cynical realm. However, after experiencing it with Clayton, I felt a legitimate perspective on the matter.
The Pain of Oversights
For all of Andor‘s success this year, the show also faced two notable snubs: Diego Luna and Genevieve O’Reilly. How do such oversights feel from within the show?
It’s incredibly painful. Genevieve O’Reilly appears in 20 of the 24 episodes, delivering a performance that is complicated, nuanced, and breathtaking. It’s a lifetime achievement. You wonder when you’ll get another opportunity like that, especially if you’ve been a working actor on the margins. I would trade many things to see her recognized. Diego is in a similar position, but I worry less about him. The impact of awards can significantly change careers, and it’s disheartening when deserving performances go unrecognized.
See More ...
The Political Nature of Art
A particularly toxic aspect of the online discourse surrounding Season 2 stemmed from those who believed the series had politicized Star Wars. What constitutes political art, in your view?
Over the past six months, I’ve been compelled to articulate my political beliefs. Initially, I tried to remain anonymous, but through numerous discussions, I identified my views as more moral than strictly political. The themes in the show can be interpreted through a moral lens, highlighting the elevation of cruelty and the diminishment of grace. Fascism strips away not only freedom but also decency and humanity.
Future Aspirations
In addition to being nominated for Best Series, you also received a nod for Original Music and Lyrics alongside Nicholas Britell for “We Are the Ghor.”
Yes! I desire this Emmy greatly. You could say I’m smiling, but I genuinely want this one.
A Musical Background
You were a musician, right?
I played music seriously for several years, but it didn’t pan out. I made a bold career shift. When Nick and I began writing, we listened to national anthems from around the world. Some are great, while others are not. I think anthem writing could be a viable side hustle.
