Subtext plays a crucial role in storytelling, allowing characters to convey deeper emotions without stating them outright. This article delves into notable scenes from films and television that exemplify this technique.
Understanding Subtext in Dialogue
In heated moments, we often express frustration in indirect ways, saying things like, “You left the toilet seat up again,” while slamming the door. This reflects a deeper sense of betrayal that we may struggle to articulate. It’s easier to argue about the bathroom than to confront the underlying feelings of hurt.
Great dialogue often avoids characters stating their true feelings outright. People tend to deflect, avoid, and dance around their emotions. Subtext is the tension that simmers beneath the surface of conversations, where the emotional truth resides.
Here are five remarkable scenes from films and TV that allow audiences to read between the lines, revealing characters through what they fear to say directly.
Ocean’s Eleven: “He doesn’t make me cry.”
This scene captivates me due to its multi-layered tension. When Danny Ocean asks Tess if Terry Benedict makes her laugh, her response, “He doesn’t make me cry,” cuts to the core of their relationship. It speaks to emotional safety, as Tess sidesteps Danny’s real question, “Do you love him?” while revealing her desire for stability over the uncertain and painful life with a thief.
No Country for Old Men: “What’s the most you ever lost on a coin toss?”
In this iconic scene, Anton Chigurh’s coin toss with the gas station owner transcends the act itself. It’s about power, fate, and the essence of life and death. Chigurh’s chilling line, “You’ve been putting it up your whole life, you just didn’t know it,” encapsulates the film’s theme: our choices either lead us closer to life or death.
See More ...
Succession: “Look how far you have come.”
This dialogue from Season 4, Episode 4, “Honeymoon States,” occurs after Logan Roy’s death. Marcia, the family matriarch, has always clashed with Connor’s partner, Willa. When Willa offers condolences, Marcia’s response, “And congratulations—look how far you have come,” carries a double meaning. While it sounds like praise, it subtly acknowledges Willa’s ascent from escort to potential family member.
Cat on a Hot Tin Roof: “It was love that never could be carried through.”
In this 1955 film, Margaret’s monologue reveals the unspoken love between Brick and Skipper. She describes their relationship as a beautiful ideal that could never be fully realized or openly discussed, highlighting the societal constraints of the time.
Crazy, Stupid, Love: “You have to fertilize once a month.”
In Dan Fogelman’s script, when Tracy asks Cal about women experiencing midlife crises, she is really questioning the justification of her affair. This painful subtext reveals her desire for permission to disrupt their lives, while Cal distracts himself with yard maintenance, avoiding the emotional turmoil of their marriage.
Share your favorite scenes that exemplify subtext!
