In a standout year for indie films addressing the challenges faced by lesbians with cancer, ‘Julian’ emerges as a poignant exploration of love and loss.
‘Julian’ Review: A Heartfelt Tragedy Navigating Illness and LGBT Rights
This year has been remarkable for indie films depicting the struggles of lesbians facing cancer diagnoses, and “Julian” is no exception. Directed by Cato Kusters, this poetic yet somewhat muddled debut explores a poignant narrative.
Plot Overview
The film follows two women on a romantic journey around the world that takes a tragic turn when one of them falls ill. It delves into themes of grief in the digital age alongside the harsh realities of terminal illness. While the premise holds promise, it leans heavily on a sentimentality that may not resonate with all queer audiences, particularly in the current socio-political climate.
Characters and Development
Based on Fleur Pierets’ heartbreaking memoir, “Julian” features Nina Meurisse and Laurence Roothooft as the central characters. Their love story begins with a classic lesbian encounter at a music venue, blossoming into a passionate relationship. When they get engaged, Fleur devises a plan to turn their wedding into a global celebration, highlighting the countries where same-sex marriage is recognized.
Emotional Depth
As the plot unfolds, the revelation of Julian’s cancer diagnosis is both gradual and abrupt, halting their travel plans. The emotional scenes with Julian’s family showcase Kusters’ ability to capture subtle expressions and collaborative performances, creating a palpable sense of fear and loss.
Critical Analysis
While the film captures the essence of personal accountability in the face of adversity, it struggles to stand out in a saturated genre. Fleur’s journey into denial and her attempts to document her partner’s life through writing serve as a poignant yet troubling distraction from reality. The portrayal of her internal conflict is compelling, yet the narrative ultimately leaves viewers questioning its intended message.
See More ...
Conclusion
“Julian” is a multi-language film that touches on significant themes for modern queer audiences. However, its execution may not resonate with everyone, particularly given the complexities surrounding LGBT rights today. The real-life narrative, while powerful, raises questions about its cinematic adaptation. Ultimately, “Julian” serves as a poignant reminder of love and loss, but perhaps it would have been better left as a personal story rather than a film.
Grade: C+
“Julian” premiered at the 2025 Toronto International Film Festival and is currently seeking U.S. distribution.
